In your response, be sure to address all parts of the question. Use complete sentences; an outline or bulleted list alone is not acceptable.

“The members of the Philadelphia convention which drafted the Constitution were, with a few exceptions, immediately, directly, and personally interested in, and derived economic advantages from, the establishment of the new system. The Constitution was essentially an economic document based upon the concept that the fundamental private rights of property are [superior] to government and morally beyond the reach of popular majorities.”
Charles Beard, historian, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, 1913

“Anxious and uncertain, the convention delegates . . . brought to bear their political experience, their sensitivities to legal loopholes, their commitment to representative government, and they focused their energies and attentions on resolving existing conflicts, correcting existing errors, and protecting . . . against a descent into tyranny. When they were done, they submitted their handiwork to the citizens for ratification rather than attempting to impose it by assassination or military force. In this way, they invited their neighbors to share responsibility for the fate of their experiment in representative government.”
Carol Berkin, historian, A Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution, 2002

Using the excerpts above, answer (a), (b), and (c).
a. Briefly describe ONE major difference between Beard’s and Berkin’s historical interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution.
b. Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event, development, or circumstance in the period 1776–1800 that is not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Beard’s interpretation.
c. Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event, development, or circumstance in the period 1776–1800 that is not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Berkin’s interpretation.

Answers

Answer 1

Answer:

a) One major difference between Beard's and Berkin's historical interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution is the point of view in which it is written. Charles Beard believes that the Constitution was adopted for economic self-interest while Berkin portrays the conflicts between the delegates during the drafting of the constitution. This was significant because the different interpretations show the development of Unites States government.

Explanation:

hope it helps :)

Answer 2

a) ONE major difference between Charles Beard's and Carol Berkin's interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution is that Beard argued that the Constitution was drafted to perpetuate the economic interests of the wealthy.

On the other hand, Berkin's interpretations focus on how the drafting of the Constitution created the national government which allows democratic norms to flourish.

b) ONE specific historical event between the period 1776 - 1800 that supports Beard's economic interpretation of the Constitution is demonstrated by the passage of the Fugitive Slave Act in 1783. The law enshrined slavery into the Constitution, making it possible for slaveholders to recover slaves who had run away.

c) On the other hand, the Shays Rebellion, which forced the drafting of the Constitution and the jettisoning of the Articles of Confederation, showed that the Constitution's drafting resolved past political errors and brought about a representative government.

Thus, Charles Beard's economic interpretations and Carol Berkin's political interpretations enjoy the needed support from historical events, developments, or circumstances.

Learn more: https://brainly.com/question/9215465


Related Questions

how did the greeks defeat the persians at salamis?

Answers

Answer:

Battle of Salamis, (480 bc), battle in the Greco-Persian Wars in which a Greek fleet defeated much larger Persian naval forces in the straits at Salamis, between the island of Salamis and the Athenian port-city of Piraeus.The Greeks sank about 300 Persian vessels while losing only about 40 of their own.

Explanation:

Brainliest to first answer!!!!!
Create a contextualizing statement for the claim below.
Consecrated in the thirteenth century and located in Jenne, Mali, the Great Mosque is one of the finest examples of West African Islamic architecture.

Answers

Answer:02.07 Social Problems and Solutions Chart

I believed that the Problem was successfully addressed because of the fact that people up to this date have abided by it

The Fair labor Standards act was passed which basically outlawed all of child labor

No it is not an issue today because it is against the law for certain aged children to be working

For the most part yes it has been, this is because more buildings were build to ensure that more people could live in them

More Tenements were built because of the Tenement Building owners realizing they could make more money if they had more Tenement housing buildings

Yes and No because there are still people that are homeless but there are enough buildings for them to live in

Child Labor

Tenement

Housing

Lack of

Protection

It was never really addressed because of the living arrangements in cities such as the building being made of wood and candles being the only source of light and burning down building forcing people out onto the street which made thieves and pickpockets thrive

Yes it has been addressed successfully because more safety precautions have been taken when making buildings

Yes, for the most part because there are security cameras and protection everywhere such as police officers and fire fighters

Explanation: put them in a chart

1. A Spanish soldier looking for a meal in an Indian home would most likely find everything EXCEPT

Answers

Beef because the cow is considered a holy animal in Indian culture

How did the french and indian war, and subsequent Cherokee War, irrevocably change Native American culture?​

Answers

Answer:

The answer is below

Explanation:

Following the French and Indian War and subsequent Cherokee war, in which the British won. The British in turn retaliate against Native American nations that sided with the French, and even those on British sides were not exempted, by ensuring that they have no supply to trades and forced them to follow rules imposed on them. Also, after defeating the French, the British have the free reign to inflict the strict rules on the Native American nations.

how did joan of arc and the hundred years war benefit france?

Answers

Answer:

Joan of Arc was a French peasant who said she was told by angels and saints to help lead the French to victory in the Hundred Years' War. She helped defeat England several times but was captured and executed for heresy.

Explanation:

what above four items have in common

Answers

Answer:

what are the items?

Explanation:

what is the climax of the great great ice cream heist

Answers

Answer:

Ima be real with you thats not even a thing

Explanation:

google people almost everything

The impeachment of President Andrew Johnson was due to

his involvement in the Confederate military during the Civil War.

a struggle between Congress and President over governmental power.

charges that he had lied under oath about Reconstruction laws.

his actions as a "Radical Republican" during the Reconstruction Era.

Answers

Answer:

b

Explanation:

Answer:

a struggle between Congress and President over governmental power.

Explanation:

Question 2 of 10
The map below shows the modern political boundaries of the Middle East.
The area highlighted in yellow is the region in which
Russia
Belarus
Poland
Ukraine
Kazakhstan
Rama)
Ma
Turkey
Urbekistan
Tuomas
China
Alpha
Ir
In
Pakia
Libya
Fort
India
Saadi Anbi
per
Yemea
Sedes
Fhiopia
Somalia
Krea
O A. Abraham established early Jewish society

Answers

Answer:

I need a picture of the map

Answer:

B. The Zoroastrian religion spread

Which of the following was NOT a reason for Barbara's protest?

Answers

Lemme see the problem and I’ll help.






Choose all of the landforms that were helpful to the ancient Egyptians.
*PLEASE NOTE YOU CAN CHOOSE MORE THAN ONE!*
A. Eastern Desert
B. Nile River
C. Mediterranean Sea
D. Western Desert

Answers

Answer:

B, D

Explanation:

I’m pretty sure B and D

Who was Khadijah? Muhammad’s wife Muhammad’s daughter a business rival of Muhammad’s an angel who spoke to Muhammad

Answers

Answer:

A

Explanation:

Give the other guy brainliest just because

Answer:  first wife of the Prophet Muhammad, a trader. Apart from the posthumous records of Muhammad's life (srah) and teachings, little is known about her (Hadith).

Why is Khadijah important and who was she?

Khadija, the prophet Mohammed's first wife, ran one of the most significant caravan trade lines in the area and was a successful businesswoman in her own right. The first Muslim, she had faith in Mohammed before he had faith in himself.

What was spoken about Khadija by the Prophet?

When Khadijah questioned the Prophet about his love for her, he said, "She adopted Islam when people rejected me; she believed in me when no No one else did, and she stood in for everyone else and gave me support when I needed it.

Which wife was Muhammad's favorite?

Most Muslim traditions refer to Khadija bint Khuwaylid as Muhammad's most cherished and preferred wife; according to Sunni tradition, Aisha is Khadija's sole rival. This idea is supported by a number of hadiths, often known as stories or sayings of Muhammad.

To know more about Khadijah visit:-

https://brainly.com/question/7038657

#SPJ2

1) According to the Preamble to the Constitution of the Knights of Labor, what threats faced workers in the late 19th century?

Answers

Answer:

Poor remuneration

Explanation:

The Preamble to the Constitution of the Knights of Labor revealed that the threats that faced workers in the late 19th century are POOR REMUNERATION.

The Constitution which was created in 1878, stated in the Preamble amongst other things, beginning with " The alarming development and aggression of aggregated wealth, which, unless checked, will inevitably lead to the pauperization and hopeless degradation of the toiling masses, render it imperative, if we desire to enjoy the blessings of life, that a check should be placed upon its power and upon unjust accumulation, and a system adopted which will secure to the laborer the fruits of his toil:..."

Low wages and unsafe working conditions.

The Preamble to the Constitution of the Knights of Labor revealed that the threats that faced workers in the late 19th century are  low wages and unsafe working conditions.

The Preamble  states that:

To secure proper share of the wealth The abrogation of all laws that do not bear equally upon capital and laborThe removal of unjust technicalities, delays, and discrimination in the administration of justiceThe adopting of measure providing for the health and safety of those engaged in mining, manufacturing, or building pursuits.The enactment of laws giving mechanics and laborers work for their full wages.The abolishment of the contract system on national, state, and municipal work.

Learn More about Constitution of Knights of Labor:

https://brainly.com/question/8168856

PLEASE HELP MEE I NEED ANSWER ASAP I REALLY NEED HELP PLEASE HELLLP18. HOW IS 'NEGOTIATION' RELATED TO HAVING TO 'COLLABORATE' WITH SOMEONE IN CONFLICT?

Answers

You can be disagreeing with someone and it can lead to negotiation.

You can negotiate and it can lead to a disagreement.

Conflict; to disagree with someone.

Negotiation; discussion aimed at reaching an agreement.

Explain the missouri compromise

Answers

Answer: It was an effort to preserve balance of power in Congress between free and slave states, Missouri a slave state and Maine a free state.

Answer:

The Missouri Compromise was United States federal legislation that admitted Maine to the United States as a free state, simultaneously with Missouri as a slave state, thus maintaining the balance of power between North and South in the US Senate.

Explanation:

name three states that would be considered "Safe" democratic states?​

Answers

Answer:

Oregon, New York, Rhode Island, Washington, Hawaii and Massachusetts are the most democratic.

Explanation:

They have not voted for a republican since 1984 and almost always vote blue.

What was the Aztec Death Whistle created to do?

Answers

Answer:

Historians believe the whistles were used in sacrificial rituals of death.

Explanation:

Aztec Death Whistles produce the loudest, most ear piercing screams you will ever hear from a whistle. A number of whistles were found with sacrificed victims to the Aztec wind God Ehecatl.

45 POINT I NEED HELP FAST
Which factor contributed to the rise of the Akkadian Empire?
O The Akkadians invaded the Fertile Crescent.
O The Akkadians encouraged Israelites to rebel.
O The Akkadians fought wars to overthrow weaker empires.
O The Akkadians managed to unite Mesopotamian city-states.

Answers

Answer: The Akkadians managed to unite Mesopotamian city-states

Explanation: Under the rule of Sargon and subsequent kings of the kingdom, the Akkadian Empire, which is considered the first acknowledged empire in history, reached a peak around the 22nd century BCE.

By conquering other countries to divide them into a single Mesopotamian empire, Sargon created the Akkadian empire and replaced existing Akkadian noble people to replace rulers.

In the west and over Elam in the east, the Akkadian empire stretched up to the Mediterranean Sea.

Answer:

Answer: The Akkadians managed to unite Mesopotamian city-states

Explanation:

To what extent did the
British and Dutch trading
companies change the
societies they encoun-
tered in Asia?

Answers

Answer:

1.In China, European scientific knowledge was sought after selectively. Qing dynasty emperors and scholars were most interested in European astronomy and mathematics. However, they had little interest in European medicine.

2.Scholars in the Ottoman Empire were broadly aware of European scientific achievements by 1650, but they took an interest only in those developments that offered practical utility, such as in making maps and calendars.

Explanation:

How did the transcontinental rail road impact the U.S.?
O
Allowed people to travel to Mexico and Canada
O Provided jobs for Native Americans
O Connected the East and West coasts

Answers

Hello how are u!!!

It connected the east and west coasts is the answer,l. hope i helped, have a great day!!

Explanation:


Can someone help me with this history hw?

Answers

honestly no lol bye lol lol lol

How do the Reardan students first react to Junior ?
1. They immediately embrace him
2. They ignore him
3. Many people stare at him

Answers

Answer:

3

Explanation:

The thirty years war involved all major European powers except which nation

Answers

Answer:

The polish lithuanian  comman wealth

Explanation:

what are some facts about chinese religion?

Answers

Answer:

Chinese religion is composed of four main traditions: Chinese folk religion, Confucianism, Taoism and Buddhism. When it comes to Chinese religion, many people have questions like: What do Chinese religions believe about God or gods, the universe, people, the spiritual realm, and the afterlife?

Explanation:

Brainly crown pls?

China is officially an atheist state with one of the lowest percentages in the world of people who consider themselves religious. Buddhism and Daoism (Taoism) are the most popular religions in China. However, there are also sizeable populations of Muslims (1-2%), and Christians (3-4%).

hope this helps ya! :)

True or False: The colonies were granted a representative in Parliament
when they complained about the English Taxes

Answers

Answer:

true

Explanation:

I hope this helps :)

Answer:

"No taxation without representation"

Explanation:

That was a part of why America and Britain went to war in the first place. So false?

How did Muhammad gain a reputation fifir being trustworthy before becoming a prophet?
O as a powerful tribal leader
as a businessman and trader
O as a member of a prominent family
O as a religious leader

Answers

Answer: I believe it is B

Explanation:

I was reading a thing and said he used to be a good merchant

He enjoyed trust as a dealer and businessman.  similar are Islam, Judaism, and Christianity as religions They all promote the idea of a single God. Hence option B is correct .

Who was Muhammad ?

Around the year 570, Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, was born in Mecca. He was raised by his uncle Abu Talib after becoming an orphan before turning the age of six. Muhammad started out as a trader and gained a reputation for being reliable.

When Muhammad was about twenty-five years old, he wed Khadija, a prosperous widow whose social standing enhanced Muhammad's standing in Meccan society.

Two sons and four girls, both of whom died infancy, were born to Muhammad and Khadija. After his marriage, perhaps fifteen or twenty years later, he started to experience visions and strange sounds.

Islamists to this today, people honor Muhammad as the epitome of the ideal believer and use his deeds and words as a guide to ethical behavior. Muhammad was a mortal, but one with amazing qualities, in contrast to Jesus, who Christians believe to be God's son.

Learn more about Muhammad here

https://brainly.com/question/6347796

# SPJ 6

What was Governor Miró’s attitude toward settlers in Louisiana?

He gave incentives only to white, northern settlers.
He encouraged new colonists to settle in the area.
He discouraged settlers from French territories.
He prevented settlers from western territories.

Answers

Answer:

He encouraged new colonists to settle in the area.

Explanation:

!!!!!HELPP!!!Its about the Cuban missile crisis!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answers

The first act signed into public law by President John F. Kennedy was a joint resolution commemorating, with proper ceremonies at the U.S. Capitol on March 4, 1961, the 100th anniversary of the first inaugural of Abraham Lincoln.

Who brought religious unity and tolerance to England while encouraging expansion
and power?
A Thomas Cranmer
B Mary Tutor
C Sir Thomas More
D Elizabeth I

Answers

Answer:

C Sir Thomas More

Explanation:

Sir Thomas More brought religious unity and tolerance to England while encouraging expansion.

He was a chancellor who got killed along with other monks for his refusal to accept the national church.

Easy 15 points and a brainly to the first one that answer
Answer in one paragraph.

What are the factors that are the most important in convincing the 55 delegates to make a change to the Articles of Confederation?

Answers

Answer:

i just answered this

Answer:The Articles created a loose confederation of sovereign states and a weak central government, leaving most of the power with the state governments. The need for a stronger Federal government soon became apparent and eventually led to the Constitutional Convention in 1787.

Explanation:Although the 55 Delegates Knew the country needed a stronger federal government, they feared that a republic could not serve a nation as large as the US...But they knew incase of national emergencies and etc. they needed to make a change.

Other Questions
Mississippi Trial, 1955 study guide questionsWho is "Bobo"? Briefly explain Hiram's encounter with him. 5. A herd of zebras has 9 males and 62 females.During a one-year period, 22 foals that are bornsurvive and 25 adults die. Six females join theherd. Three males and 11 females leave the herd.Has the herd reached its carrying capacity for thisecosystem? How do you know?O a. The herd has reached its carrying capacitybecause the growth rate is negative.Ob.The herd has reached its carryingcapacity because the growth rateis positive.O c. The herd has not reached its carrying capacitybecause the growth rate is negative.Od.The herd has not reached its carryingcapacity because the growth rateis positive. Mike discovered an error in his checking account register and when he recalculated his balance hewas overdrawn in the amount of -$738.57. Mike saved two of his paychecks in the amount of $300.40each in case of emergencies. If Mike deposited the amount he saved, what would be his current balance? Need help ASAP !!! I am failing MATH Which statement below best describes the connection between photosynthesis and respiration? *1 pointBoth have the same products.Both have the same reactants.Both require energy from the sun.The products of one are the reactants of the other. could men age 17 or older who did not own property vote Trading(buying and selling) of goods is an example of ______ as an exploration motive.Required to answer.Single choice.(10 Points)A. GodB. GloryC. GoldD. Goodness Can someone help me solve this like atleast give 50$ 75$ Ill give you 100 points or brainlist Ill work for the 100 points dont answer if wrong If Coach Smith has 12 players and each player needs three uniforms, three shin guards, two balls, and three pairs of cleats. How much will he end up spending on his equipment for the entire soccer team? Kevin rented a truck for one day. there was a base fee of $17.99, and there was an additional charge of 95 cents for each mile driven. Kevin had to pay $157.64 when he returned the truck. for how manny miles did he drive the truck? PAY ATTENTION FOR MEGA POINTS!!!Sam has 6 eggs. She broke 2 of them, cooked 2 of them, and ate 2 of them. how many eggs are left? i will give brainly answer. im not smart and cant think for myself. please and thank you:)compare and contrast coal and nuclear power. would you support either of both of these forms of energy technology. why or why not? what are the five lessons or skills you learned in your t.l.e 9 A detention hearing without a jury shall be held promptly, but not later than the second working day after the child is taken into custody; provided, however, that when a child is detained on a Friday or Saturday, then such detention hearing shall be held on the first working day after the child is taken into custody. Group of answer choices what is a futur tense I need to know how to input this into python on zybooks. I've been stuck on this for days and I keep running into "invalid syntax" or "unknown word red" Summary: Given integer values for red, green, and blue, subtract the gray from each value. Computers represent color by combining the sub-colors red, green, and blue (rgb). Each sub-color's value can range from 0 to 255. Thus (255, 0, 0) is bright red, (130, 0, 130) is a medium purple, (0, 0, 0) is black, (255, 255, 255) is white, and (40, 40, 40) is a dark gray. (130, 50, 130) is a faded purple, due to the (50, 50, 50) gray part. (In other words, equal amounts of red, green, blue yield gray). Given values for red, green, and blue, remove the gray part. Ex: If the input is 130 50 130, the output is: 80 0 80 Find the smallest value, and then subtract it from all three values, thus removing the gray. What is the element name for 3.3% Governments pass laws that limit carbon emissions in order to __________.A.conserve water resourcesB.reduce air pollutionC.protect the soil from erosionD.increase fuel efficiency in cars and trucks HELP ME PLEASE!!! this is a timed testttt 14. While traveling in Greece, you see columns of all different orders. You examine each one carefully. You see one with capitals that havetwo rows of leaves that fan out from them and four scrolls. Which order do you infer you are observing?1(.Sumerian2).Doric3).Ionic4).Corinthian